
The Bar of Ireland
Orchard Way, Killarney V93Y9W9.
DX: 51010 Killarney
Tel: (087) 4361270
Patrick's legal education is robust, beginning with a BCL Law Degree from University College Cork (2012-2016), followed by an LL.M in Business Law from the same institution (2016-2017), and culminating in a Barrister-at-Law Degree from The Honorable Society of King’s Inns in Dublin (2019-2021). He has extensive experience on the South-West Circuit, handling Civil, Family, and Criminal Law cases, as well as advising the Citizen Advice Service. He has worked as an employment consultant, dealing with workplace investigations and bankruptcy procedures.
Background:
The Complainant began working as a Customer Care Team Lead for the Respondent on January 4, 2019, with an annual salary of €40,000. Her employment was terminated on October 23, 2023, which she attributed to her vocal concerns about the Palestine conflict. Following her dismissal, she made several attempts to find alternative employment, registering with recruitment agencies and applying for various roles. She eventually secured a position with An Post on May 20, 2024, with a weekly salary of €532.65. The Complainant claimed a total loss of €25,000 in earnings between her termination and new employment and contended her ongoing financial loss due to a lower current salary. She also asserted that the public nature of her dismissal and comments from the Respondent’s leadership negatively impacted her job search and career prospects. She cited the Labour Court determination in a related case to argue for compensation, noting the lack of procedural fairness in her dismissal. During cross-examination, the Complainant confirmed applying for 60 jobs and starting her role at An Post, where she appeared uncertain about promotion and overtime opportunities. She claimed blacklisting in the tech sector and disputed the Respondent's assertion that her reputation remained intact despite receiving political support and positive social media comments.
The Respondent acknowledged procedural unfairness of the Complainant's dismissal and asserted that the focus should be on determining appropriate compensation under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977. The Act limits compensation to financial loss, with no provision for emotional distress or punitive damages. Legal precedents emphasising that compensation should reflect actual financial loss, including prospective loss, but not non-financial impacts. The Respondent argued that compensation should be based on the Complainant's net salary and highlighted that she began a lower-paying job with An Post in May 2024. The Respondent challenged the adequacy of the Complainant's efforts to mitigate her loss, noting insufficient documentation of her job applications and current employment details. The Respondent concluded that while compensation is warranted, it should strictly reflect the Complainant's financial losses.
Finding:
The Adjudicating Officer found the Complainant was unfairly dismissed by the Respondent, with compensation limited to financial loss, excluding emotional distress or punitive damages. The Complainant, previously earning €40,000 annually, experienced a loss of income during her 26-week unemployment period and continued to earn less in her current job. The Complainant's efforts to mitigate her loss were deemed insufficient due to inadequate documentation and a lack of substantial job application evidence. Based on the financial loss suffered and considering the requirements for diligent job-seeking efforts, the Adjudicating Officer awarded the Complainant €35,000 in compensation for her unfair dismissal.
Practical Guidance for Employers:
Employers should ensure procedural fairness in all dismissal processes to avoid unfair dismissal claims. Clearly document and follow established procedures, including proper notice and opportunity for employees to address concerns. Maintain thorough records of all employment actions to support your case if disputes arise. Encourage dismissed employees to actively seek new employment and document their job search efforts, as this can affect compensation outcomes. Understanding that compensation is limited to financial loss under the Unfair Dismissals Act 1977, it’s crucial to mitigate potential liabilities by adhering strictly to fair dismissal procedures and maintaining comprehensive documentation.
The full case can be found here:
https://www.workplacerelations.ie/en/cases/2024/july/adj-00048434.html
Continue reading
We help hundreds of people like you understand how the latest changes in employment law impact your business.
Please log in to view the full article.
What you'll get:
- Help understand the ramifications of each important case from NI, GB and Europe
- Ensure your organisation's policies and procedures are fully compliant with NI law
- 24/7 access to all the content in the Legal Island Vault for research case law and HR issues
- Receive free preliminary advice on workplace issues from the employment team
Already a subscriber? Log in now or start a free trial